Local Backup vs. Cloud Backup: Pros, Cons, and Why You Need Both

• December 21, 2025

• Comment
• Facebook
• Twitter
• Bluesky
• Reddit
• LinkedIn

Choosing how to back up your digital life used to be simple: you bought an external drive, plugged it in, and hoped for the best. Today, the choice between local and cloud backups can feel like a philosophical debate about ownership versus convenience. The truth is that neither is perfect on its own, and understanding their strengths is the first step toward never losing a file again.

The Case for Local Backups

Local backup refers to any system where your data stays on physical hardware you own and control. This usually means external hard drives, SSDs, or a Network Attached Storage (NAS) device sitting on your desk.

The biggest advantage here is speed. If you’ve ever tried to restore 500GB of photos from the cloud, you know it can take days, even on a decent connection. With a local drive, that same restore happens as fast as the cable can carry the data. You also have total control over your privacy; there’s no third-party company involved, no passwords to lose to a data breach, and no monthly subscription fees.

However, local backups have a glaring weakness: they are physically tethered to your location. If your house suffers a fire, flood, or theft, your backup drive is likely to disappear right along with your computer. They also require a bit more manual attention. Even with automated software, you have to ensure the drive is plugged in and healthy. Hard drives are mechanical devices, and they eventually fail.

The Case for Cloud Backups

Cloud backups involve sending your data over the internet to a provider’s servers. Services like Backblaze, IDrive, or even the backup features built into iCloud and OneDrive fall into this category.

Convenience is the king here. Once you set it up, it usually runs in the background without you ever thinking about it again. It’s “off-site” by definition, meaning your data is safe even if your entire home office is destroyed. Most modern cloud providers also offer versioning, which allows you to “roll back” a file to how it looked three days ago—an absolute lifesaver if you accidentally overwrite a document or get hit by ransomware.

The trade-offs are speed and trust. Your backup speed is limited by your internet’s upload bandwidth, which is often much slower than your download speed. You’re also trusting a company to keep your data secure and stay in business. While encryption handles the privacy side, you are still dependent on their infrastructure.

Why You Should Probably Do Both

In the world of IT, there is a gold standard called the 3-2-1 backup rule. It suggests you should have:

1. Three copies of your data (the original and two backups).
2. Two different types of media (e.g., a local drive and the cloud).
3. One copy off-site (the cloud backup).

By using both, you get the best of both worlds. If you accidentally delete a folder, you can grab it instantly from your local drive. If your laptop and its travel drive are stolen from your bag, you can still recover everything from the cloud once you get a new machine.

Getting Started

If you don’t have a backup system yet, don’t overthink it.

1. Buy an external drive. Aim for something with at least twice the capacity of your computer’s internal storage.
2. Set up built-in tools. Use Time Machine on macOS or File History on Windows to automate the local backup.
3. Pick a cloud provider. For a set-and-forget experience, look at dedicated backup services that offer unlimited storage for a flat yearly fee.

It’s tempting to wait until you have the “perfect” setup, but a simple backup today is infinitely better than a sophisticated one you plan to set up next month. Your future self will thank you when the inevitable “disk not found” error eventually appears.

• backup
• storage
• privacy
• security

Comments